Reason why women go see ‘X-men origins: Wolverine’

 

 

I’d say the above graph (cute and inspired by stereotype though it may be) is reflective of the popular perception of women and comic books.  For me this is entirely inaccurate, but I’ve come to realize that my love of comic books is the exception and not the rule.  I don’t think the percentage of women who read comics is that small, but it certainly isn’t as high as the number of men who read comic books.  Granted, this graph is for amusement and contains no real data.  I’ve been searching for demographic numbers and to my surprise, I haven’t found any.  When I do, I’ll pass them along.  That doesn’t dismiss the perception portrayed, though.

I was the only girl I knew growing up who liked Comic Books, and try as I might, I can still only count on one hand the number of women I know who read comic books and graphic novels (and I don’t even need an opposable thumb for that tally).  At first this was discouraging, particularly because of some of the amazing work the industry is doing (Let’s not think about the Divas project, shall we?) with their female characters, and what some of the female writers are working on.  There’s no reason for girls and women to feel like comic books are some kind of walled garden they have to experience in secret or from the outside looking in anymore. 

When we went to our local comic shop for Free Comic Book Day, something happened that brought tears to my eyes.  I was crouched down looking for the missing issues of Wonder Woman that I’ve recently become obsessed with, when two little girls began buzzing around me and looking over my shoulder.  First, I was surprised to see little girls in a comic book shop to begin with, and second, I was even more surprised when I noticed that they had a few comics clutched tightly in each of their hands.  The one girl looked at the stack resting on my knee and back up at me.  “Do you like Batgirl? I love Batgirl, she’s my favorite superhero!  I’m trying to find more Batgirl comics”

I was floored. 

I helped her look for more Batgirl comics and the ones we found she already had.  Then she buzzed away to go help her friend look for the comic books she liked.  Seeing the absolute joy in their faces as they pulled comic books off the shelf and found what they were looking for… just seeing them absolutely elated to be in that shop made me choke up.  And I kept my mouth shut.  There were no brazen opinions about Batgirl being a mere “female version” of a popular super hero, or that it’s embarrassing that they couldn’t come up with an original concept for her, or that the political and social commentary in the current Batgirl issues would be over her head… no.  I just helped her find the comic books of a character that made her happy.  So what if she didn’t think those things?  So what if she wasn’t deconstructing everything from thought balloons to story arcs?  I realized that those little girls enjoyed Batgirl and the other comic books because they somehow related to the characters… they liked the stories and the action and the art.  They liked them because they are fun.

So yeah, you can have your Batgirl, honey.  I may like my deconstruction of story lines and character portrayals, but ultimately, it boils down to some simple concepts.  It’s fun.  It makes me smile.  It’s an escape and a comfort all at the same time, and they give you hope.  Isn’t that what comic books are for?

And who’s to say that little girls (or little girls at heart) can’t or don’t appreciate that?

I’m going to see X-Men Origins: Wolverine because I read the comic books, and because I want to see how it translates to film. 

I’m going to have fun.

Tags: , , , ,

This entry was posted on Friday, May 22nd, 2009 at 10:59 am and is filed under Comic Books, Feminism, Social Commentary. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

4 comments so far

anon
 1 

How refreshing!

I have to say me and my girlfriends liked comic books growing up, but I doubt we’re the norm.

Leave your critical side in the lobby for Wolverine. I enjoyed it, but it is definitely flawed. I hope you have fun!

May 22nd, 2009 at 5:20 pm
Hannah
 2 

It’s stories like that make me smile. It’s stuff like that reminds why I want to work in comics or at least at comic book store. But yeah, that’s pretty amazing

May 26th, 2009 at 11:47 pm
 3 

Here via WFA! - and I just want to say your site design is gorgeous.

I loved the story about the little girl; watching girls get into comics always fills me with such joy.

On the piechart side, I’m happy to pretend the made up numbers are reasonably accurate, but I’d put it down to a function of the movie, not of the audience. Hugh Jackman naked is more or less the only thing the movie has going for it; I certainly wouldn’t recommend it to someone who wants to see a faithful and intelligent story about characters they already know.

May 27th, 2009 at 4:37 am
 4 

@Anon — I wish I would have had friends like yours growing up! It was brutal enough that I liked reading and books and they saw learning as a chore. Gods help you if you ask them to use their imagination without a Barbie!

@Hannah — Agreed! I’m still trying to figure out a way to own a comic shop… and welcome!

@Debi — Welcome! I just stumbled on to WFA! recently and love the variety and wealth of info! And thanks for the site compliments! :)

And I’m pretty sure I’ll try and leave my Critic’s hat at home when I see Wolverine… I can’t promise it though. Bad habits die hard, and I have a feeling that film is begging for some analysis.

May 27th, 2009 at 10:26 am

One Trackback/Ping

  1. Reality 101 - Class is in session… » Blog Archive » Oh, I’m Buying Marvel Divas, All Right…    Jun 01 2009 / 12pm:

    [...] slumber parties and drinks and non-committal sex?  This has to be pandering to the population of women who just want to see Hugh Jackman naked, right?  So rather than build on the strong characters you have, with legitimate story lines, with [...]

Leave a reply

Name (*)
Mail (will not be published) (*)
URI
Comment